Learning space for complete music.

ToneGym

profile
Neil Gilmartin
Oct 04, 2022
Has anyone else experienced confusion when playing Chordelius because you are absolutely convinced that neither of the chord choices you're given are what is actually being played? I am sure that I was hearing a standard major triad but the 'correct' answer was an add2. Of course I could be wrong - that's why I'm here, after all! - but I'm pretty sure that, in this case, I was right and the choices were not accurate.
profile
Cuantas Vacas
Oct 04, 2022
What the elf is an 'add2' chord? Why nobody told me? What else are you hiding, ToneGym??😁
profile
Neil Gilmartin (author)
Oct 04, 2022
An add2 is a major or minor triad (root, third and fifth) but with the second added in as well (root, second, third, fifth).
profile
Cuantas Vacas
Oct 04, 2022
I didn't want my comment to sound disrespectful towards your question, @Neil Gilmartin . I'm sorry if that was the case, but my only intention was to joke about the fact that, despite all the years of studying music theory plus 2 on ToneGym, I wasn't aware of the existence of a name for such chord extension -being some kind of alternative sounding add9.
I just need my imagination to know that the sound of such artifact is not going to sound pleasing to me, unless it's arpeggiated, so I got a little 'shocked' when I saw 'add2' written down for the first time. It was perfect material for a joke, please bear with me...

Wait! Then there must be also an 'add4'...!😂
profile
Neil Gilmartin (author)
Oct 07, 2022
It didn't sound disrespectful, Cuantas. That never even crossed my mind. But yes, in the game, the option of add2 is given, not add9. I guess they are literally adding a second note below the major 3rd rather than than an octave up. But still, my point was that I'm sure what I was hearing was a major triad - no additions, no extensions - yet the answer was 'add2'. Although I am starting to doubt myself now...
profile
Seighart Bui
Oct 07, 2022
It might be a bug. Maybe you should report it?
Add2 chords don't exist. if all 4 notes are within an octave, it would be a block chord and it would still be called an add9
profile
Cuantas Vacas
Oct 07, 2022
The discussion about the 'existence' of Add2 chords is sterile. The fact that I haven't ever consciously listened it, or seen it written down on any staff I can remember, or even my opinion about its absurdity can never imply that chord doesn't exist. 'Exist' is a big word...
profile
Neil Gilmartin (author)
Jan 16, 2023
profile
Neil Gilmartin (author)
Jan 16, 2023
From an excellent ear training course on macprovideo / ask video.

I think it's valid to use 2, 4, and 6 when you don't have a 7 in the chord. Using 9, 11, or 13 implies that there is also a 7 somewhere, but using 2, 4 or 6 makes it clear that there is only the basic triad and then the addition of notes below the 7, not an extended chord in other words.

Can’t delete that post above for some reason…
profile
Victor Wilburn
Jan 16, 2023
Sure, there's been lots of time I've been wrong when I really thought I was right. ;)
profile
Cuantas Vacas
Jan 17, 2023
Your last explanation makes total sense to me. It's always nice to learn new things, and it's great to have this helpful community!! Thanks @Neil Gilmartin !